Explore More Blogs
You've just sat through a brilliant agency pitch. The strategy sounds solid. The team seems capable. You're ready to sign.
Then, three months in, you discover the $15,000 monthly retainer includes undisclosed media markups. Or you try to leave and find yourself locked into a 90-day termination clause that costs you another $45,000 in fees while you search for a replacement.
This article is your protection checklist. Not what to do after problems emerge, but what to demand before you sign anything.
Three things matter most: cost transparency, performance accountability, and exit flexibility. Ask for these upfront, and you'll avoid the expensive surprises that trap most businesses. If you're evaluating agencies now, the team at Seogrowth can help you navigate these conversations with confidence.
You're not being difficult by asking these questions. You're being smart.
Standard agency contracts favor long lock-ins, vague deliverables, and bundled costs that hide where your money actually goes. This isn't a conspiracy. It's just how the industry works.
Agencies naturally protect their revenue stream. That means 90-day termination clauses, auto-renewals that reset those clauses, and unclear ownership terms for the work you paid them to create. Some contracts don't even specify who owns the audience data or creative assets if you part ways.
This isn't about distrust. It's about starting with balanced terms that protect both parties. A confident agency won't resist transparency. They'll welcome it.
The problem is structural. Most businesses don't negotiate these terms because they assume the contract is standard and non-negotiable. It's not. Everything is negotiable before you sign.
Bundled pricing hides the true cost. When an agency quotes you $30,000 per month for "full-service marketing," you can't tell if you're paying $5,000 for strategy or $5,000 in hidden media markups.
The fix is simple: separate media spend from agency services to understand costs and ensure no hidden management fees apply for planning, buying, and reporting.
Demand a line-item breakdown showing the agency fee separate from every dollar of media spend. Here's what that looks like in practice:
Option A: $10,000 monthly retainer + $20,000 media spend (itemized by channel).
Option B: $30,000 "all-inclusive" package with no breakdown.
Option A lets you see exactly what you're paying for. Option B hides everything.
A 15% agency fee sounds reasonable until you realize it's calculated on inflated media spend. Some agencies pad the media costs, then take their percentage of the padded total.
Transparency matters more than the rate. You can negotiate fairly when you see the real numbers. You can't negotiate when everything is bundled into one opaque figure.
Don't focus on finding the "right" percentage. Focus on seeing where every dollar goes.
A proper breakdown should include:
Each line should show what you're paying for and what's excluded. Request line-by-line breakdowns including specified exclusions and extras so there are no surprises later.
Red flag example: "Marketing services: $15,000" with no further detail. That tells you nothing.
Vague success metrics let agencies claim wins while your revenue stays flat. "We increased impressions by 40%" means nothing if you didn't gain a single customer.
Before any work begins, define measurable criteria such as a $20 million boost in revenue or a 15% increase in brand equity. Get it in writing.
The demand is simple: a written agreement on specific KPIs tied to business outcomes, not just marketing outputs. Agencies comfortable with clear metrics are confident in their ability to deliver. Those who resist probably aren't.
Vanity metrics—impressions, reach, engagement—look good in reports but don't pay your bills. Revenue metrics do: leads, sales, customer acquisition cost.
Clarify goals as leads, sales, foot traffic, or awareness aligned with business objectives. Be specific.
Good example: "Generate 50 qualified leads per month at a cost per lead under $200."
Bad example: "Increase social media followers."
Awareness metrics aren't useless, but they need to connect to a business outcome. Awareness that leads to trial, consideration, or purchase matters. Awareness for its own sake doesn't.
Waiting 30 days to see results wastes budget. Problems compound. By the time you spot an issue, you've already spent thousands on underperforming campaigns.
Monthly reporting with weekly or fortnightly check-ins is standard for small businesses working with agencies. Weekly check-ins catch problems early.
Reports should include performance against agreed KPIs, spend breakdown by channel, and next-month strategy adjustments. Make it clear this should be in the contract, not just a verbal promise.
If you're unsure how to structure these reporting requirements, the team at Seogrowth can help you set up accountability frameworks that actually work.
Long termination periods trap you with underperforming agencies. You keep paying while searching for a replacement. That's expensive and frustrating.
Frame this as a mutual benefit. Agencies confident in their work don't need 90-day lock-ins. They know you'll stay because the results justify the cost.
The demand: 30-day termination notice with no penalties, and clear ownership of all work created during the engagement. Difficult exit terms are a red flag about agency confidence.
Thirty days is reasonable. It's enough time for transition, not so long you're stuck paying for poor performance. Ninety-day clauses cost you three months of fees even after you've decided to leave.
Some setup-heavy work might justify 60 days initially—building a new website, for example. But ongoing work like campaign management should be 30 days.
Do not accept auto-renewal clauses that reset long termination periods. If your contract auto-renews for another 12 months with a 90-day termination clause, you're effectively locked in for 15 months.
Some contracts give agencies ownership of creative, strategy documents, and even audience data you paid to build. That's unacceptable.
You own all deliverables, creative assets, and data generated during the engagement. This should be explicit in the contract.
You paid for this work. Ownership should transfer to you upon payment. Ad creative, landing pages, email templates, audience lists—all of it should be yours to keep.
Example: If the agency built a library of ad creative for your campaigns, you should be able to take that creative and use it with another agency or in-house team. If the contract says the agency retains ownership, you're starting from scratch when you leave.
Negotiation isn't confrontational. It's a signal. Agencies that welcome these questions are confident and transparent. Those that resist probably have something to hide.
Pushing back on unfavorable terms establishes you as an informed partner, not a passive client. Chemistry and strategic alignment matter more than speculative creative. Start the relationship with honest conversation.
Use these demands as your pre-signing checklist:
Walk away from agencies that resist transparency. They're not protecting their business. They're protecting their ability to overcharge you.
Protecting yourself upfront prevents expensive problems later. If you need expert guidance navigating these conversations or want help evaluating agency proposals, Seogrowth specializes in helping businesses make informed marketing decisions. Get in touch for a consultation.
