Explore More Blogs
You're paying someone to grow your business. They send reports. They attend meetings. They talk about strategy. But when you look at your revenue, nothing's changed.
This isn't rare. Most agencies are structured to retain clients, not deliver outcomes. The difference matters because one keeps you paying monthly fees whilst your competitors pull ahead.
Here's how to spot the difference before it costs you another quarter of flat performance.
Strategy sounds impressive. It fills meetings. It justifies retainers. But if you can't connect their strategy to a number that matters to your business, you're funding theatre.
Good agencies tie every recommendation to a measurable outcome. They'll tell you what they expect to happen, by when, and how they'll know if it worked. They don't hide behind jargon or promise "brand awareness" when you need leads.
The problem is that talking about strategy is easier than delivering results. It requires less accountability. If an agency can keep you focused on process instead of performance, they can stay on retainer indefinitely whilst your growth stalls.
When you're evaluating your current relationship or considering a new partner, visit Seogrowth's homepage to see how a results-focused approach should look. The difference becomes obvious quickly.
You get a monthly PDF. It's full of graphs. Impressions are up. Engagement looks healthy. But you can't trace any of it back to a sale, a qualified lead, or a dollar of profit.
Impressions, clicks, and page views mean nothing without context. A campaign that generates 10,000 impressions but zero enquiries is a failure, not a success. Yet many agencies will present that 10,000 as progress.
Ask yourself: does your report show how many leads came in? How many converted? What the cost per acquisition was? If those numbers are missing or buried, your agency is reporting activity, not results.
A useful report connects digital activity to business outcomes. It shows you which channels are profitable, which need work, and where to allocate more budget. Anything less is decoration.
If your agency can't explain how their work contributed to revenue this month, they either don't know or don't want to tell you. Both are problems.
Good agencies track attribution. They know which campaigns drove enquiries, which keywords converted, and what the return was on every dollar spent. They'll show you this without prompting because it's the only thing that matters.
When an agency avoids this conversation, it's usually because the numbers don't support the retainer they're charging.
You shouldn't have to ask what's happening with your campaigns. If you're the one initiating every check-in, something's wrong.
Agencies that care about your results stay in front of you. They respond quickly. They don't reschedule meetings three times or leave your emails unanswered for days.
Poor communication is a major red flag; clients should not have to chase the agency for responses or updates. When this becomes a pattern, it signals that you're not a priority.
A reliable partner treats your time with respect. They show up prepared, they follow through on commitments, and they keep you informed without you having to ask.
If you're always the one asking "How are we tracking?", your agency isn't managing your account, they're reacting to it.
Results-focused agencies bring performance updates to you. They flag issues early, suggest adjustments, and keep you in the loop on what's working and what isn't. They don't wait for you to notice a problem.
This proactive approach is what separates agencies that care about outcomes from those that are just processing tasks.
Marketing that doesn't evolve stops working. If your agency is running the same campaigns they set up six months ago without testing anything new, they've stopped trying.
Autopilot has its place, but only after you've tested, optimised, and proven what works. Most agencies skip that part. They set up a few campaigns, let them run, and hope you don't notice the performance plateau.
A good agency is constantly testing. New ad copy. Different audience segments. Alternative landing pages. They're looking for incremental gains because they know that's how you stay ahead.
If your agency isn't suggesting tests, they're not thinking about your growth. They're thinking about their workload.
You should be hearing new ideas regularly. Not every month, but often enough that you know your agency is actively looking for ways to improve your results.
When an agency goes quiet on recommendations, it usually means they've run out of ideas or they're not invested enough to develop new ones. Either way, you're paying for maintenance, not growth.
Every agency will eventually suggest increasing your budget. That's not the red flag. The red flag is when "spend more" is their only answer to underperformance.
If your campaigns aren't working, throwing more money at them rarely fixes the problem. A competent agency knows this. They'll look at targeting, messaging, conversion rates, and landing page performance before they ask for more budget.
When an agency defaults to "you need to spend more" every time results dip, they're either lazy or they don't know how to optimise what you're already running. Both are unacceptable.
Good agencies obsess over efficiency. They want to get you more results from the same budget, not just scale up spend and hope for the best.
This means cutting underperforming campaigns, reallocating budget to what's working, and constantly refining targeting and creative. If your agency isn't talking about this, they're not managing your money properly.
If you're dealing with this issue and need a partner who prioritises efficiency, explore Seogrowth's services to see how a performance-driven approach works in practice.
Your agency should understand your business well enough to push back when you're wrong. If they just nod and execute whatever you ask for, they're not adding value.
When an agency gives you advice that could work for any business in any industry, they haven't done the work to understand yours.
Useful recommendations are specific. They reference your customer behaviour, your sales cycle, your competitive position. They're grounded in what actually happens in your market, not what works in theory.
Generic advice is a sign that your agency is managing you like a commodity, not a partner.
You're not always right. Neither is your agency. But a good agency will tell you when they think you're making a mistake.
If your agency agrees with everything you say, they're either not paying attention or they're too worried about losing your business to be honest. Both are problems.
The best agency relationships involve healthy disagreement. You should be debating strategy, testing assumptions, and challenging each other to think differently. That's how you get better results.
If an agency can't market themselves effectively, why would you trust them to market your business?
Look at their website. Read their content. Check their social media. If it's outdated, generic, or poorly executed, that's what you're paying for.
An agency that does not market itself well may not be reliable, as effective self-promotion can be indicative of their capability. This isn't about perfection. It's about whether they practice what they preach.
If your agency is pushing SEO but their own site doesn't rank, or they're selling paid ads but don't run any themselves, ask why.
Sometimes there's a legitimate reason. Often, there isn't. And when an agency doesn't use the tactics they recommend, it suggests they either don't believe in them or don't know how to execute them properly.
Busy doesn't mean effective. If your agency is celebrating how much work they did instead of what they achieved, you're paying for effort, not results.
A typical update from a weak agency sounds like this: "We published four blog posts, ran three ad campaigns, and updated your social media calendar."
A strong agency says: "We increased qualified leads by 18% this month by refining audience targeting and testing new ad creative."
The difference is focus. One is reporting activity. The other is reporting outcomes.
When an agency talks about how hard they worked or how many hours they put in, they're trying to justify their fee without showing results.
You don't care how hard it was. You care whether it worked. If your agency can't tell you what changed as a result of their work, they're not measuring the right things.
A good agency doesn't just avoid these red flags. They actively do the opposite.
They report on metrics that matter to your business. They stay ahead of you with updates and recommendations. They test constantly. They optimise for efficiency before asking for more budget. They know your business well enough to challenge your assumptions. They practice what they recommend. And they measure success by outcomes, not activity.
This isn't complicated. It's just rare.
If you're reading this and recognising too many of these warning signs in your current relationship, it's worth having a direct conversation. Ask your agency how they measure success. Ask them to connect their work to your revenue. Ask them what they've tested recently and what they plan to test next.
Their answers will tell you everything you need to know.
If you're ready to work with a partner who prioritises results over retainers, contact Seogrowth to discuss how a performance-focused approach can change your trajectory. Learn more about their approach and what makes them different.
